Friday, December 26, 2008

What the US owes the world

by Eric deCarbonnel

Owen F. Humpage and Michael Shenk explain the US's net international investment position (what the US owes the world). Reading this article is necessary to understand a point I make below, which is that the amount the US owes the world has doubled in 2008 to around 5 trillion.

(emphasis mine)

The Net International Investment Position
Owen F. Humpage and Michael Shenk

The United States has run a current account deficit almost continuously since 1982. We have financed this deficit by issuing financial claims, such as stocks, bonds, and bank accounts, to the rest of the world. Since 1986, foreigners have held more claims on the United States than U.S. residents have held on them, or, in the jargon of international finance, the United States has maintained a negative net international investment position. Last year, that negative position reached a record $2.5 trillion.





These financial instruments give foreigners a claim on future U.S. output, so economists often gauge them as a share of GDP. Last year, our negative net international investment position reached 17.7 percent of GDP, down from a record 19.5 percent in 2002.

In addition to annual current-account deficits, year-to-year adjustments in the international investment position reflect changes in the valuation of previously issued, outstanding financial claims. Valuation changes can result from movements in the market price of the underlying assets, but in recent years a substantial proportion of the valuation changes also resulted from the dollar’s depreciation. The dollar has depreciated approximately 26 percent on a trade-weighted basis against our key trading partners since early 2002. When the dollar depreciates, a fixed amount of foreign currency translates into a greater number of dollars.
Because most U.S. claims on foreigners are denominated in dollars, a dollar depreciation increases the dollar value of U.S. claims on foreigners. On the other hand, that depreciation has little effect on the dollar value of foreign claims on the United States, which are typically denominated in dollars.



Valuation changes have had a profound effect on our net international investment position since the end of 2001: Our cumulative current-account deficit has increased nearly $3.9 trillion, while our net international investment position has increased only $0.6 trillion.
The difference primarily reflects valuation changes that work in our favor.



Reflecting the increased integration of global financial markets, both U.S. and foreign financial claims have increased much faster than U.S. GDP since the mid 1990s, especially since 2001. Contrary to reports that some foreign governments have been diversifying out of dollars, foreign official holdings of U.S assets have increased steadily by 5 percentage points since 2001. Official reserves accounted for 19 percent of foreign claims on the United States in 2007. U.S. holdings of foreign securities have also increased their share of total U.S. claims on foreigners in recent years ; they now account for 43 percent of that total. Direct investments, however, have been shrinking as a share of both U.S. claims on foreigners and foreign claims on the United States.




My reaction:
I believe the US's net international investment position (what the US owes the world) has worsened enormously in 2008. Official figures aren't available yet, so there is currently no way to verifying this. However, simple common sense tells us it must be the case. Consider the following points:

1) The US stock market has outperformed most foreign markets this year (easy to do since fed can print dollars to prop up the market). This means that the valuation of US assets abroad decreased far more than the valuation of foreigned owned assets at home. To illustrate this point,
here is a chart of year to date country stock market performance through November 2008:

2) Hedge fund deleveraging and redemptions forced the selling of US assets abroad at discound prices, decreasing the amount of US assets held abroad. This forced selling also means the US has essentially locked in the losses shown on the chart above.

3) The misguided "flight to safety" which began in the second half of the year undoubtedly increased foreign claims on US assets. It still amazes me how anyone could think that dollars and treasuries are safe.

4) Finally, The foreign claims on US assets most likely increased at least 600 billion as a result of the US's trade and current account deficits.


Conclusion: My bet is that the amount the US owes the world more than doubled in 2008, from 2.5 trillion to 5+ trillion. Since our GDP for 2008 is likely to shrink to close to 10 trillion, the US now owes around half its GDP to the rest of the world. This is not good for the dollar.

pencil icon, that\
3 Comments:
Anonymous said...

Truely scary estimates..

Yohay said...

Will we see a renewed collapse of the dollar as traders come back from the holidays?
Or this huge debt and its impact already known to everyone?

Eric deCarbonnel said...

My guess the dollar will trend lower as traders come back from the holidays, then at some point it will make a sharp break lower. I know what will be the catalyst which causes the dollar's collapse to speed up (it might be a breakout in gold prices or an announcement by China.), but my bet is it happens soon.

Key Entries

Subscribe feeds rss Recent Entries

Category Cloud

News Developments

Interesting Background Information

Blogroll

Links

Recent Comments

Subscribe feeds via e-mail
Subscribe in your preferred RSS reader